Skip to main content

Stash Status: M.A.C Lip Pencils

M.A.C Lip Pencils...talk about a product I've gone back and forth about. My current view is if there's a unique enough colour that you like - that you're going to use often - get it. Otherwise they're plenty other affordable lip pencils on the market. P L E N T Y.

Pro Longwear Lip Pencils

Sigh. These are heart breaking. Excellent staying power on the lips but boy do they dry out in the packaging. At that point they're still usable but the application process is noticeably more difficult.

M.A.C says: "A new form of long-wearing lip pencil technology that saturates lips in rich colour. A new generation of long-wearing lip pencil technology. Glides on fluidly and adheres instantly. Defines the lips with an instant release of rich, saturated colour. The transfer-proof formula prolongs the hours between reapplication.

Key Claims and Benefits

  • Long-wearing, 8 hours
  • Smudge-proof
  • Transfer-resistant
  • Non-feathering
  • Provides stay-true colour 
Usage

Apply directly to lips before or after any M·A·C Lipstick or Lipglass application
". Currently available in 28 shades. Each pencil contains 1.2 g / 0.04 US oz. of product and retails for $20USD.

I have four shades and I really really will try to not be lured by any more.

M.A.C Pro Longwear Lip Pencils www.modenmakeup.com
M.A.C Pro Longwear Lip Pencil swatches www.modenmakeup.com
T - B: 'RiRi Woo', 'More To Love', 'Shock Value' and 'Staunchly Stylish'

Soap and water wouldn't remove those swatches; I had to reach for the Bioderma.

M.A.C Pro Longwear Lip Pencils www.modenmakeup.com

You can see in the photo above how the product 'draws away' from the packaging after a while. 'Staunchly Stylish' (top) is the newest of the bunch so that's how it's supposed to look. And don't be blaming it on my sharpener either, I only use the Urban Decay Grindhouse on these.

'RiRi Woo' Lipstick and Pro Longwear Lip Pencil swatch www.modenmakeup.com
'RiRi Woo' Lipstick and Pro Longwear Lip Pencil

'More To Love' Pro Longwear Lip Pencil swatch www.modenmakeup.com
'More To Love' Pro Longwear Lip Pencil

Regular Lip Pencils

Cult favourites.

Marketing blurb: "A pencil in a wide range of colours designed for shaping, lining or filling in lips. A pencil designed for shaping, lining or filling in the lip. Lip Pencils have a smooth, creamy texture that is perfect for outlining lips or colouring them in. They are available in a wide selection of colours that each work well with many different lipstick shades.

Key Claims and Benefits

  • Features a smooth and creamy formula
  • Features a texture that won't skip or drag
  • Applies quickly and precisely
Usage

Apply directly to lips before or after any M·A·C Lipstick or Lipglass application
". Currently available in 42 shades (WOW). Each pencil contains 1.45 g / 0.05 US oz. of product and retails for $16.50USD.

So you're getting more product for less money than the aforementioned type. Looking at the ingredients on the packaging - since M.A.C doesn't list them on the website - the major difference I see in the formula is that the Pro Longwear version contains more waxes and silicones. Yet, the regular formula applies easier in my opinion. They got it right with the 'creamy' claim.

M.A.C Lip Liner ingredients - www.modenmakeup.com


I have four shade presently and I still have my eye on three more.

M.A.C Lip Pencils www.modenmakeup.com
M.A.C Lip Pencils swatches www.modenmakeup.com
[Click photo to shop]
T - B: 'Nightmoth', 'Chestnut', 'Whirl' and 'Heroine'

These swatches removed easily with soap and water with the exception of 'Nightmoth' which took a bit more elbow grease. The application was smoother than with the Pro Longwear formula. Speaking of 'Nightmoth', I already have a backup of that - it's my favourite vampy shade

M.A.C Lip Pencil 'Nightmoth' Special Packaging www.modenmakeup.com

Lip pencils do not qualify for the Back to M.A.C programme so if you get a shade you don't find yourself using I'd suggest that you destash it quickly to try and recoup some funds, if possible.

M.A.C Lip Pencils www.modenmakeup.com

'Whirl' (second from top) is the newest of the bunch. 'Heroine' (top) is showing the most exterior packaging breakdown.

Tom Ford 'Rouge Fatal' + M.A.C 'Nightmoth' swatch www.modenmakeup.com
[Click photo to shop]
Tom Ford 'Rouge Fatal' + M.A.C 'Nightmoth'

M.A.C 'Heroine' Lipglass + Lip Pencil swatch www.modenmakeup.com
'Heroine' Lipglass + Lip Pencil

Which formula is your favourite? What shades do you think I should check out? Let us know in the comments.

Popular posts from this blog

M.A.C Shiny Pretty Things Haul

In the most tardy local M.A.C Holiday release ever, Shiny Pretty Things was made available when the new store finally opened in The Colonnade Mall on December 3rd.


From YouTube chatter, it seemed like the eyeshadow singles and the Extra Dimension Skinfinish 'Snowflushed' were the hot ticket items. 'Snowflushed' is supposedly a big pan of 'Stylishly Merry'. To me, those thing were definitely mesmerizing to look at but the lip glasses were the unexpected stunners.


At this point, M.A.C items in limited edition packaging are collector's pieces. Right? Right. I was more looking at what would make great gifts.

T - B: 'Scarcely Seen', 'Rosebuddy' and 'Caketop'
Of course I had to get a bullet lipstick...

Matte Metallic 'Straight Fire'
The matte bright fuchsia 'Both Cheeks' looked gorgeous too but we all know I barely wear pink lipstick.


Just like the Nutcracker Sweet Collection they also released sets of minis. They claim these…

Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser

Usually I do these cleanser reviews when I've used the product for a while. Typically a little before half the product is gone. Well...


...this is almost done. I was using this in the shower and yuh know, time just got away.
From the Beautylish site:
"About Brightening Cleanser
A customer favorite that washes away impurities to leave skin soft, refreshed, and luminous. The combination of its proprietary blend of fruit oils, lycopene (from tomatoes) and hydrolyzed wheat protein (from wheat) - make it ideal for cleansing, hydrating, tightening, firming, and complexion control. Gently wash away makeup and impurities with this antioxidant-rich formula. Strawberry Seed Oil, Hydrolyzed Wheat Protein and Tomato extracts help strengthen, firm and protect, leaving the skin hydrated, silky and luminous. Doubles as an exfoliating mask if left for 5 minutes before rinsing.

Who It’s For
Ideal for of all skin types especially those with uneven texture and dullness.

How to use
Apply a small amo…